Wednesday, January 11, 2012

The Bean Trees - Barbara Kingsolver

When I was teaching, I was often forced to read swill then pass it along to my students without letting them know that I thought the book was a waste of time. Yet another mandatory read, The Bean Trees by Barbara Kingsolver is a flop. Because Kingsolver is such an acclaimed author I can only assume her other works are phenomenal, however, if they are all written like this one, I fear there is no hope for the literary public. Had I picked up this novel of my own accord, I would have seen that the media commentary printed boldly across the top of the cover was from Glamour magazine; not exactly the choice I would have made had there been better comments to choose from. But alas, this is another book I was asked to teach to my junior class, and by golly, I was going to get through it if it killed me!

I think my biggest frustration with the novel isn’t the fact that the story is boring and lacks a clear direction; my biggest complaint is that the protagonist, Taylor Greer, is a completely inconsistent character. She changes her persona to conform to the situations at hand. If I were asked a simple question ranking higher on the Blooms scale such as, “How do you think Taylor would react to [blank] situation,” I would be completely unable to answer intelligently because the author has given no clear indication of WHO Taylor is at the root of her being. What is the point in trying to TEACH with a book so poorly written? How am I supposed to lead students’ understanding of character development if there is no development to be had? I understand this was Kingsolver’s first novel and I also have been told by many people how great some of her later works are (Poisonwood Bible being one of them). Why the textbook adoption committee at any school district would choose this novel as a mandatory read when there are clearly better books to be read is beyond my ability to fathom. Being forced to read poorly written and/or boring books is the reason many teenagers despise reading.

There will be no summary left for this one mostly because I don’t care to revisit the story to provide one. I would like to make one thing clear: my anger is not toward the author. This was her first book. With experience comes the ability to string a great novel. My anger has been caused by the fact that this novel found its way to a mandatory reading list at the high school where, at the end of the semester, I had too many students admit books like this one were the reason they didn’t read.



  1. I think she is completely overrated period. I have tried to read the pig book, can't remember the name and poisonwood bible for book clubs. They both bored me to tears and I actually threw them both in the trash. Something I never do with books. Ugh, can't stand her.

  2. I've never read it, but I can categorically state that I hated EVERY SINGLE BOOK I was made to read at school, with a particular loathing for Cider With Rosie, which was probably an English teacher's wet dream, and an English student's worst nightmare! Alas, we have to do a whole pile of exams at grade 10 level over here, and that was one of my assigned texts - I think it's miraculous I even passed that exam, let alone got a C, because our literature choices were dire. It may, of course, have been being made to analyse the books to death (and my tendency to argue against illogical things - who are you to say what the author thought, have you asked them? No? Then how do you know you're right and I'm wrong...? ;o) )


Comments make my day! Seriously. I love them.

Related Posts Plugin